6 min read

Choosing an Executor for Your Will: Navigating the Sensitive Topic with Family

Conversations about death are difficult. But legal positions, Will specifics and handling of the estate after you're gone? That’s a lot of overwhelming responsibilities to add into the emotional, death-conversation mix. Read on for our top tips on navigating these difficult conversations with family, and avoiding conflict ahead of time.

Difficult conversations

Selecting an executor for your Will is one of the most critical decisions in estate planning. An executor plays a vital role in ensuring your final wishes are carried out, assets are distributed, and affairs are settled according to your instructions.

However, approaching the sensitive topic of executor selection with family members can be challenging. In this comprehensive guide, we explore the importance of choosing the right executor, discuss potential challenges in the selection process, and provide helpful strategies to approach this delicate conversation with your loved ones. Because, lucky for you, we’ve been here before.

Understanding the Role of an Executor

Before delving into the topic of executor selection, it is essential to understand the crucial responsibilities an executor undertakes. Understanding exactly what an executor does can help inform your choice of who might be up to the job. Similarly, it might make you think a professional executor is a better choice for you, and your family.

The executor's duties include:

  • Identifying and valuing assets in the estate.

  • Paying off debts and taxes owed by the deceased.

  • Distributing assets according to the terms of the Will.

  • Handling administrative tasks and paperwork related to the estate.

  • Communicating with beneficiaries and resolving any disputes that may arise.

Choosing the right executor is vital to ensure these responsibilities are fulfilled with care, efficiency, and integrity. It’s a huge commitment to do so, and choosing well can make or break the ease of estate administration for other family members left behind.

The Significance of Executor Selection

Selecting an executor is not a decision to be taken lightly. The chosen individual or institution will be responsible for carrying out your final wishes and ensuring your legacy is preserved. They need to deal with lawyers, banks, tax offices and (sometimes hardest of all) other family members.

With this in mind, an executor should possess several key qualities:

  • Trustworthiness: The executor should be someone you trust implicitly with sensitive matters and financial affairs.

  • Organisational skills: A capable executor should be detail-oriented and able to handle administrative tasks efficiently.

  • Communication: Effective communication skills are crucial to ensure a smooth process and address any concerns that may arise. Things might get heated amongst family and its important to executor is able to communicate clearly amid that.

  • Impartiality: An executor must act impartially, putting the interests of all beneficiaries first.

Identifying Potential Challenges

Approaching the topic of executor selection with family members can be emotionally charged; leading to conflicts and disagreements if it's mishandled.

For some, the role might have emotional attachments and selection might be taken personally. Complex family dynamics such as sibling rivalries or past conflicts can also play a role in complicating the selection process- making it harder to select someone who is impartial.

Similarly, competing interests and different opinions can create difficulties in choosing an executor. Each family member may have their own interests, and it’s tricky to make the decision with so many emotions involved.

Initiating executor conversations

Initiating a discussion about executor selection with family members can be overwhelming, so it’s worth being prepared ahead of time. Take it from us, when we say that thinking through your own decision before broaching it with the wider family, can help bring clarity to emotional conversations.

Here’s our top tips to prepare:

  • Reflect on your decision: Take time to consider the best candidate for the role of executor based on their abilities, availability, and trustworthiness. Try to be fair and open-minded, whilst also keeping in mind that the executor should be on board with your wishes and intentions.

  • Communicate openly: Be transparent about your reasons for selecting a particular individual as executor and explain the responsibilities involved. Helping family members understand your decision can increase acceptance.

  • Emphasise your intentions: Clearly express your desire to make the best decision for the well-being of your family and the efficient administration of your estate. Keeping focus on common ground can help avoid disputes

Having the Conversation

Approaching the topic of executor selection requires sensitivity and empathy. You're dabbling in sensitive death-taboo grounds, and so it's understandable that emotions are heightened.

With this in mind, there's often a time and a place for such conversations. In a busy restaurant, at a special occasion or after a stressful day at work, you might not be getting the best from people. Choosing a comfortable and private environment to discuss can help reach more productive outcomes.

Similarly, it’s important to be respectful and patient when having discussions about executor of estate, or your death at all. Hearing out thoughts and concerns, and avoiding getting defensive, are all conducive to better long term outcomes.

Whilst it’s important to allow family to air their concerns, it’s also essential that you communicate your reasoning and emphasise the reasons behind your decision. Maybe the chosen executor has more time or financial experience which will help them navigate the role, or maybe it's due to your relationship with them. Either way, try to focus on the executors qualities, rather than the family members lack thereof.

Finally, if a family member is keen to help out, you could consider appointing multiple executors. Whether it's as a back-up or as a co-executor, this can be a helpful compromise which shares the responsibilities and addresses concerns about impartiality.

Dealing with conflicts

Even with the best prepared, most sensitive conversation intentions- family disputes can still occur. Seeking the assistance of a third-party or getting professional advice can help reroute disagreements to productive discussions.

Or, if you decide to revisit your executor decision, it's worth noting that you can make changes to your Will which reflect changing family dynamics. You could even decide to appoint a trusted friend or professional executor to take on the role, and the responsibilities.

Get started today

Write your Will today, and get a head start on planning ahead for the future. Whether it's appointing your executor, assigning beneficiaries or setting out end of life wishes, a Will is the best way to see that your estate goals are carried through.

For more info, reach out to one of our compassionate experts on 1800 103 310 , or via live chat now.

Last updated 26th July 2023
1 D69 B666 12 C4 4 E1 A B9 D0 A98325 C7 A6 B9 4 5005 c
Hannah Comiskey
For Charities
FAQs Blog
The best way to contact our Customer Care team is via our
Call us at
1800 10 33 10
Safewill acknowledges all Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Traditional Custodians of Country and recognises their continuing connection to land, sea, culture and community. We pay our respects to Elders past and present.
Safewill is an online service providing streamlined forms and information. Safewill is not a law firm or a substitute for a lawyer’s advice about complex estate planning issues.